Obituary

In 1968, shortly after the Russian invasion and occupation of Czechoslovakia, Dr Arthur Fisch, an Auschwitz survivor, relocated with his wife and 8-year-old Paul from Bratislava to Bad Neustadt an der Saale (West Germany). Paul studied medicine with an internship in Neurology in Cologne. After residency in Internal Medicine in W€ urzburg, Paul joined Paul Sondel’s group at the Carbone Cancer Center at the University of Wisconsin in Madison, as a Leukemia Society of America Fellow. He was then awarded a German Research Foundation scholarship to work with Terry Rabbits at the Laboratory of Molecular Biology in Cambridge, UK. Paul returned to Germany as a group leader and Leukemia Society Fellow in the Department of Hematology and Oncology at the University of Freiburg, completing a Habilitation degree in Immunology under Thomas Boehm. Paul was then awarded the prestigious Heisenberg scholarship, joining Hans-Georg Rammensee’s department at the University of T€ ubingen, where he completed a Habilitation in Immunology and Molecular Genetics. There he also received the Artur-Pappenheim-Award from the German Society of Hematology and Medical Oncology. In 1998, Paul returned to Freiburg as Professor of Molecular Pathology at the Institute for Clinical Pathology. In 2016, on his return from a scientific trip to Buenos Aires, Paul suffered a fall causing two vertebral fractures. Subsequent medical intervention and further complications thereof ultimately led to his death on 26 November 2018. Paul was a true pioneer of cd T cell research, interested in multiple facets of the cells’ biology. Drawing scientific insight from meticulous investigation of human clinical data and cell culture systems, Paul made profound contributions to our understanding of cd T cells, and to cancer immunology more broadly. After the wholly unanticipated discovery of the TCRc chain and the subsequent discovery of cd T cells, some immunologists doubted that cd T cell antigen recognition would differ from that of ab T cells. However, word emerged from the Sondel lab in Wisconsin that – incontrovertibly – peripheral blood cd T cells kill haematological malignancies in the absence of known MHC I or MHC II elements. The young clinician scientist Paul Fisch spearheaded these studies, bringing his findings to the 1990 International Workshop on the ‘Specificity and Function of cd T cells’ at Schloss Elmau in Bavaria, Germany. Paul’s time in Madison was fundamental to both his professional and personal life. Not only Paul’s scientific discoveries, but also his friendships from those years would carry on for the rest of his life (Figure 1). In his seminal paper on cd T cell specificity, Paul was one of the first to describe the molecular mimicry that allows cd T cells to be shaped by infections but also to recognize tumour cells. In addition, Paul showed that cd T cells can be subdivided into distinct subsets according to their cytotoxic responses, and that while inhibitory receptors typically found on NK cells likewise control cd T cell cytotoxicity against Daudi lymphoma targets, cd T cells are functionally distinct from NK cells. These important discoveries set the landscape for a wave of studies about the role of NK receptors on cd T cells, and

In 1968, shortly after the Russian invasion and occupation of Czechoslovakia, Dr Arthur Fisch, an Auschwitz survivor, relocated with his wife and 8-year-old Paul from Bratislava to Bad Neustadt an der Saale (West Germany). Paul studied medicine with an internship in Neurology in Cologne Paul was a true pioneer of cd T cell research, interested in multiple facets of the cells' biology. Drawing scientific insight from meticulous investigation of human clinical data and cell culture systems, Paul made profound contributions to our understanding of cd T cells, and to cancer immunology more broadly.
After the wholly unanticipated discovery of the TCRc chain 1 and the subsequent discovery of cd T cells, 2,3 some immunologists doubted that cd T cell antigen recognition would differ from that of ab T cells. However, word emerged from the Sondel lab in Wisconsin thatincontrovertiblyperipheral blood cd T cells kill haematological malignancies in the absence of known MHC I or MHC II elements. The young clinician scientist Paul Fisch spearheaded these studies, bringing his findings to the 1990 International Workshop on the 'Specificity and Function of cd T cells' at Schloss Elmau in Bavaria, Germany.
Paul's time in Madison was fundamental to both his professional and personal life. Not only Paul's scientific discoveries, 4-6 but also his friendships from those years would carry on for the rest of his life ( Figure 1). In his seminal paper on cd T cell specificity, Paul was one of the first to describe the molecular mimicry that allows cd T cells to be shaped by infections but also to recognize tumour cells. 5 In addition, Paul showed that cd T cells can be subdivided into distinct subsets according to their cytotoxic responses, 6 and that while inhibitory receptors typically found on NK cells likewise control cd T cell cytotoxicity against Daudi lymphoma targets, 7 cd T cells are functionally distinct from NK cells. 4,6 These important discoveries set the landscape for a wave of studies about the role of NK receptors on cd T cells, and their innate immune responses in tumour immunity, 8,9 which remains a very active research field. 10,11 With these early studies, Paul moved a large and important stone into place on the pathway to recognizing cd T cell biology as unique and clinically profound. Indeed, Paul's work has proven prescient, as reflected in the wealth of strategies under development to harvest this potential. Biotech company founders in the cd T cell space agree that Paul's discoveries provided scientific underpinnings that have enabled progress towards clinical trials. Beyond his early work, Paul continued to make crucial contributions as a sharp, fair reviewer and critical discussion partner for these companies. Naturally, Paul's research also continued in this vein, with recent papers on enhancement of tumour cell killing via manipulation of the cd T cell antigen receptor 12,13 and analysis of cd T cells infiltrating triple-negative breast cancers. 14 Paul not only thought about science, he also loved performing experiments! His keen interest in how natural phosphoantigens activate cd T cells led Paul to bring a huge dry pellet of Daudi cells to Jean-Jacques Fourni e in Toulouse for chromatographic separation. Careful analyses revealed only trace amounts of these very labile metabolites, unfortunately an unpublishable result. Undeterred, the duo screened a collection of~2000 natural product extracts that Jean-Jacques had assembled during family holidays. Paul consistently observed activating compounds in these samples, pointing to ubiquitous stimuli for these unconventional T lymphocytes. More recently, while studying the diversity of cd T cell expansions in immunodeficient patients and analysing the underlying mechanisms, Paul substantially improved the TCRc and d spectratyping method through intense laboratory experimentation. 15 Paul was a central figure in the cd T cell arena, highly respected for his honesty, work ethic and outstanding commitment to research. Paul's eminent role was honoured with his appointment as a chairman for the 2010 cd T cell meeting in Kiel, Germany. Then, when the next organizers were unable to host the following conference, Paul stepped up and, together with Wolfgang Schamel, rescued the 2012 cd T cell meeting on short notice. Paul wrote a conference grant application to the German Research Foundation that, hastily signed on the hood of Paul's car under a street lamp on a dark and drizzling Sunday evening, was thankfully successful! 16 Paul was also important to the cd T cell community on a personal level. Paul warmly welcomed researchers from other fields and befriended newcomers at cd T cell conferences. Deeply committed to family, Paul would sometimes bring one of his children to cd T cell meetings, and could carry on discussions about the unexpected characteristics and multifunctionality of cd T cells while picking out colourful doughnuts! Not without some measure of unforeseen disarray, Paul was a generous and reliable collaborator, and helped junior and senior researchers alike gain a step up into the cd T cell world by freely sharing his expertise and support. Paul inspired a new generation of scientists to pursue greater knowledge of cd T cells. Many scientists cloning cd T cells use Paul's protocol, 4 often accompanied by his personal guidance.
Paul also collaborated with clinicians outside of the cd T cell field, studying patients with inherited immunodeficiencies and analysing the consequences of hypomorphic mutations in genes critical for VDJ recombination. 17 This intriguing work was the beginning of several interesting discoveries in this area spanning over a decade, the most recent published in Blood in 2016. 18 Paul's additional non-cd T cell studies included thymoma-associated immunodeficiencies 19 and hematopoietic cell transplantations. 20 Paul was a quiet and humble person, with a demeanour that belied his vast intelligence. In his calm, friendly and reassuring way, he treated his conversation partners as equals, thereby instilling confidence in those who sought him out. It was easy to speculate and hypothesize with Paul, as he was an excellent listener, was very well read and his comments were thoughtful, pragmatic and to the point. Paul stood by his ideas, which collaborators and competitors alike sometimes found challenging, but they would always recognize the benefits of his input nonetheless. Paul's way of thinking might affectionately be described as a sort of 'creative chaos', as might his appearance, but his mind was sharp and analytical.
Paul was a loyal friend, and an encouraging and generous mentor. He was quirky, yet warm and open not only with friends, but also with collaborators and students; discussions often went beyond science, to include family, philosophy or politics, sometimes over d€ oner kebab or cheesecake and fine coffee. Those who were close to him appreciated Paul's special sense of humour, humanity and kindness.  In his final year, Paul impressed all those around him with his energy and scientific drive, despite his failing health. Paul's unstoppable vision was to develop the use of cd T cells for anticancer immunotherapy. As such, he mustered his remaining strength, will and passion to rally scientists to form a German consortium to analyse the role of cd T cells in cancer, and submitted a funding proposal to the Deutsche Krebshilfe. When awarded an invitation to proceed, Paul fought his ill health to prepare for the defence in viva voce. With his iron will to advance science, Paul disregarded his deteriorating health, travelling to Bonn to defend his dream. On this unforgettable day, those with him shared moments of excitement, laughter, anger, eagerness and empathy. Despite his weakened state, Paul was following his passion and was therefore happy. He passed away a few days later, never having learned the outcome.
The news of Paul's death came as a shock to all who knew him. Paul was a rare combination of kindness of heart and keenness of mind, and we feel very lucky to have had him as a friend and colleague. He brought us an abundance of beauty, inspiration, originality, authenticity, kindness and love. We sincerely hope Paul's wife Anja, daughter Nora and sons David and Aron will find some comfort and solace in knowing what an indelible impression Paul left on so many of us. He did not need a long life for us to measure. It was, rather, we who needed his life to be longer, and though he is gone, his unconditional love for science will continue to inspire us.